The Usability Post
Thoughts on design and user experience by Dmitry Fadeyev

In UI Design, the “Obvious” Solution isn’t Necessarily the Best Solution

One of the nice things about the Mac OS X operating system is the attention and the little touches that may seem illogical at first but then make complete sense when you think about them.

One of these things is the scrollbar arrows. OS X scrollbars have two arrow buttons, up and down, just like Windows – but the difference is that they’re both located at the bottom. The up and down arrows are stuck together at the bottom of the scrollbar, like this:

Why is it so? Isn’t it more logical to put the up arrow at the top, and down arrow at the bottom? Sure, that would seem to be the most straightforward solution – however, think about how you use those controls.

You move the mouse to the button and click on it to move the scrollbar in the direction of the arrow. What if you overrun a little? You’d need to move to the other button and click on that. Considering that you’re going to have to move your mouse to at least one arrow in the first place, Apple conveniently placed them together, so there is only one location to move the mouse to. If you click one button too many times, you have to move the cursor just a few pixels to get to the other button.

Once the user learns where both the scroll buttons are located, they’ll enjoy faster access to both of them. I think it’s a great example of an interface element where the most “obvious” approach isn’t necessarily the best one when you consider how that element is used.

“For even falsehood, uttered by the tongue of man, seemed like truth and light before this hopelessly-deaf and unresponsive silence.”

My new book: a translation of selected short stories by Leonid Andreyev, the father of Russian Expressionism from the Silver Age of Russian literature. A piercing, pitiless glance into the heart of the human condition.

☛ Read online

Further Reading

Proust wrote that the true voyage of discovery is not to visit strange lands, but to possess other eyes, to behold a hundred universes that each of them beholds. Thus, in the words of Ruskin, what good books give us is not mere knowledge, but sight.

Sign up to my email newsletter to receive regular recommendations of exceptional books on a wide range of topics including design, art, history and philosophy. A summary of my latest posts will also be included. Sign up below: